Free Speech and Social Media: Where Are the Boundaries?
The town square is private, and the rules are unclear.
Speech law was built for an era of print and broadcast. Social media collapsed the distance between speaker and audience and put the whole conversation on platforms owned by a handful of companies. The First Amendment limits the government; it does not limit the platforms, which set their own rules. The result is a constant fight over what gets removed, who decides, and whether the platforms are publishers, common carriers, or something the law has not caught up to. Censorship and moderation look alike from the outside; the difference is who is doing it and why. The stakes are not abstract. Speech that is legal offline can end a career online, and speech that is banned online can be entirely legal offline. Where should the line be, and who should be allowed to draw it?
