Supreme Court Leaves in Place Rulings That Trump's Grant Cancellations Violated Researchers' Free Speech
The justices declined to disturb lower-court decisions on University of California research funding the administration tried to end.
Reporting (NBC News, Nov. 16, 2026): NBC News reported that the Supreme Court on Monday rejected President Donald Trump's move to cancel academic funding for researchers in California, leaving in place lower court rulings that said the government violated free speech rights by terminating grants issued to University of California researchers. According to NBC, the grants came from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities, and the federal government tried to end $324 million in funding to University of California institutions, although some funding has since resumed. The researchers who sued alleged that grants were cut based on keyword searches for words such as "diversity" or "climate change." NBC reported that a federal judge and the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals both agreed with the plaintiffs, but that the appeals court separately ruled the researchers would have to file in the Court of Federal Claims to recoup lost funding. Source: "Supreme Court rejects Trump over academic funding cuts related to DEI," NBC News, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/supreme-court-rejects-trump-academic-funding-cuts-dei-rcna608885 WTF Political Rant opinion: Whatever you think of diversity programs, deciding who gets public research money by scanning for disfavored words is a lousy way to run a grant system, and it would be just as lousy if a future administration of either party built a different list of banned words. The courts here protected a principle that cuts every direction: the government does not get to punish researchers over viewpoint. The catch, per NBC's reporting, is that winning on free speech does not automatically put money back in the lab, because the researchers may still have to bring a separate claim to recover what was cut. A principled win followed by more paperwork is cold comfort to anyone whose project stalled. The administration is entitled to set funding priorities; it is not entitled to do it with a keyword search and no reasoning. Discussion question: If the next administration screened grants for the words it dislikes, would you still call that acceptable?
